Cities as Provocation with Paul van Herk

In this episode, we speak with Paul van Herk—architect, urbanist, and lecturer at RMIT—about his particular mix of humour and frustration towards our cities, with a focus on Melbourne and its numerous failed urban ventures, including the long-troubled Fisherman's Bend precinct. Paul has recently completed his PhD titled 'Urban Myths: Counterfactuals for Articulating Political Dissonance,' and his work functions as a kind of mythbuster and provocateur towards the forces that make cities—or rather, prevent their making.

Paul's research and design projects produce cut-through cultural and political insights, directing public discourse and opening new spatial opportunities for complex urban sites. He applies knowledge drawn from extensive international experience—including roles at McBride Charles Ryan, MVRDV, and Snøhetta, a Research Fellowship at Strelka Institute, and co-founding EXCX, a collaborative practice designing playful public installations for government authorities seeking to reactivate public spaces post-pandemic.

 

The voice of Paul's provocation is a spicy mix of hilarious and exasperated—but always hopeful, and well-armed for the often absurd situations that define modern city-making. This conversation is for anyone who has ever wondered why cities so frequently fail to live up to their own ambitions, and what it might look like to design—and advocate—differently.

SUP is hosted by Ian Nazareth, Graham Crist and Christine Phillips.  

This podcast is produced with support from the Alastair Swayn Foundation and the RMIT University School of Architecture & Urban Design.

We acknowledge the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups on whose unceded Country we are recording this podcast.

Show Notes and References

People + Teams  

Paul van Herk 

Joseph Campbell (1904-1987)  

  • American professor of literature looking at comparative mythology 

Liam Young (b. 1979)  

  • Australian film director and architect looking at the intersection of design fiction and critical design 

Joseph Graeber (1961-2020)  

  • American anthropologist and activist challenging narritives surrounding debt, bureaucracy, work and human history  

Rutger Bregman (b. 1988)  

  • Dutch historian and author focused on radical utopian ideas for society  

 

 

Global Case Studies  

Fisherman’s Bend Precinct (Melbourne, 2024-current)  

What killed Fisherman’s Bend? (Paul van Herk and Gabriela Amstalden Martins, 2024) 

  • Urban research project on the failure of the Fisherman’s Bend renewal precinct project.  

Melbourne's delayed Fisherman’s Bend redevelopment labelled 'biggest planning failure in Australia's history'  

Matthew Guy’s impact from rezoning Fisherman’s Bend  

Suburban Rail Loop (Melbourne, 2022-ongoing) 

  • 90km railway project that connects suburbs and makes travel faster around Melbourne 

Westgate Tunnel (Melbourne, 2026) 

  • 8km tunnel linking Yarraville and Port Melbourne   

The Matrix (Lana Wachowski, Lilly Wachowski, 1999)  

  • Filmed in Sydney because it ‘looks like a generic US city’ 

 

Theories + Planning  

Planet City (Liam Young, 2020)  

  • A short film providing a window into an alternative urban future that has been created as an antidote to the climate crisis. 

Urban Myths: Counterfactuals for Articulating Political Dissonance (Paul van Herk, 2025)  

  • Paul van Herk’s PhD research  

The New Normal Final Project Review (Strelka Institute – Moscow, 2018)  

  • Produced from Paul Van Herk’s time as a research fellow at the Strelka Institute  

 

 

Literature + Critical Perspectives   

The Death and Life of Great American Cities – Jane Jacobs, 1961 

Bullshit Jobs – David Graeber, 2018 

Learning from Las Vegas – Robert Venturi and Denise Scott Brown, 1972 

 

 

See Also 

ARM Architecture: Building the impossible and making a culture (Vivian Mitsogianni, 2016)  

ARM Architecture and the big public (Rory Hyde, 2016) 

The writing on the wall: the language of buildings (Tom Wilkinson, 2019) 

Previous
Previous

Singapore with Tat Haur Lee

Next
Next

Tarntanya/Adelaide with Ian McDougall